To our valued customers;


   Over a year ago we made a decision to alter our business plan so we could continue to create Custom Cakes for our customers.  We are a little over a year into the change and it has become very clear that Custom Cakes are something we have to back away from going forward. I realize this is a big deal and we don’t take this change lightly.
We have looked at countless ways to be able to continue to provide these custom cakes for our customers at a price that the market will bear and still have it make sense in terms for our business.  Unfortunately, we are not able to do this due to the labor and specialty products we use to produce these cakes

  Custom Cakes are just not something we can continue.  While this is a big change for all of us at Sarah’s, we are excited to be able to expand on what we do well in our business.

  Our offerings will be growing in the next few months but will still include our line of Pre-Designed Cakes, Wedding Cakes, “Small Bite” dessert line, Cupcakes, Cheesecakes and Corporate Dessert items.  Business decisions are very difficult to make, especially when emotions come into play.  I value each and every one of you that has let Sarah’s be a part of your past celebrations and hope we can continue to be present in future events.

  The past 16 years has shown me that our customers are loyal and love the products that we produce.  I am looking forward to this new chapter in our business and many years to come.



Jill Umbarger


About Us

Sarah’s is a locally-owned business that was established in 2003.  What began as a small café & catering company in Wildwood, Missouri, turned into a specialized dessert destination.  In 2010, Sarah’s made the move to Chesterfield, Missouri, and focused more on cakes, desserts, and cupcakes. At that time, we also added St. Louis' first dessert truck to our family. 2015 brought on more expansion and the need for a second dessert truck.  While the sweeter side of the business continued to grow, we never lost our passion for our small café roots, so in 2016 we decided to bring our extensive dessert and updated café menus to historic Old Towne Eureka, Missouri.

select a location


10 Clarkson Wilson Centre

Chesterfield, MO 63017




  Monday: 8:00 am - 2:00 pm

Tuesday-Saturday: 8:00 am – 6:00 pm


127 S. Central Ave.

Eureka, MO 63025




Sunday: 8am-2pm (breakfast menu ONLY)

Monday - Closed

Tuesday: 7:30am-5pm (kitchen closes at 3pm)



Lunch/Dinner 11am-8pm
Shop open until 9pm

Happy Hour 3-5pm (Wednesday-Friday)




testimonials View more...


Copyright© 2019 Sarah's Cake Shop & Sarah's On Central. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Domain 85