Custom Cakes

All of our custom cakes start at $125.00 and require an appointment with one of our cake consultants. The cake design must be finalized and payment made in full by 3 weeks prior to your event date.


Since we are a custom cake shop, we can only accommodate a certain amount of custom cakes per week. The amount of orders we can produce depends on the size and intricacy of the orders. If you book your appointment, you are only securing your appointment time; we cannot guarantee that we can accommodate the size or intricacy of your cake.


During slower months, we may be able to achieve a quicker turn around, but during wedding season and other busy months, we may not be able to accommodate all custom cake requests. Please keep this in mind when planning your events. We want to ensure the highest quality finished product for each customer and the best service we can provide.


If we cannot accommodate your custom cake request, we have many other beautiful and delicious options. We have a selection of 9 sizes of predesigned cakes that can all be customized with a message, sprinkles, and predesigned fondant plaques. We also offer custom cupcakes, along with a wide variety of glitter bites, cake pops, truffles, and many more small bites that can be arranged to make a beautiful dessert presentation.

Whether the intention of your celebration is simple elegance, vintage charm, dramatic glitter, or whimsical, a Sarah’s Custom Cake is the perfect choice for special celebrations or those where custom design, flavor, or color matching is required. Our Cake Designers build your dream cake from the ground up, taking your vision and creating something that is unique to your event. Our custom cakes are 3-layers of cake and 2 layers of filling and are 5” tall and available in a variety of flavor combinations.


To order a custom cake, please email us or book online to request an appointment with one of our cake designers. Be sure to indicate the date of your event so we can check for availability.  Custom cakes start at $125 and include a 45-minute consultation with a designer.  For smaller events, you can check out our other cake options;  Celebration, Specialty, Confetti, Standard, Rosette, Classic, Present, Petite Unicorn and our new line of unique Posh cakes..


Email for further questions.


For our predesigned cakes, which are available same day, please click here.


Visit our Pinterest and Instagram pages to see the latest Custom Cakes designs.

testimonials View more...



Copyright© 2019 Sarah's Cake Shop & Sarah's On Central. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Domain 85