Cake Flavors

White, Chocolate, Yellow, Almond, Lemon


Strawberry*, Red Velvet*, Carrot*, Banana*, Hummingbird*


* Extra Charge

Specialty Fillings

Mousse: Dark, Milk or White Chocolate

Jam: Strawberry or Raspberry

Cream Cheese Frosting: Regular or Lemon

Flavored Buttercream: Chocolate, Strawberry, Raspberry or Lemon

Ganache: Dark or White Chocolate


Download a PDF of our

menu and cake pricing

Custom CakesView Photos:Birthday CakesKids CakesBridal & Groom CakesSculpted CakesReligious CakesGraduation CakesBaby CakesCorporate Cakes

Whether you are celebrating a birthday, graduation, retirement or a golden anniversary, Sarah’s can create a cake as unique as your event. Our cakes are 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling and are 5” tall, available in a wide variety of flavors and fillings.


Our custom cakes are iced and filled with butter cream plus include color borders and your special message.  Additional charges for special and custom design.  Sculpted 3-D cakes starting at 100.00.  Please allow 3-4 weeks for fondant figurines, sculpted cakes and over the top designs.


Need a cake quote?  Please contact us with the following information: Servings needed, design concept and date needed. Please send a picture if available.

In order to assure that we can make your custom cake, 2-3 week notice is recommended especially during a holiday season.  Sarah’s takes pride in creating a quality product.  We believe in quality over quantity.  So please call early to get your special event put on our calendar.


For our predesigned cakes, which are available same day, please click here.


Custom Cakes are 4 layers of cake with 3 layers of buttercream.   Specialty fillings extra.


6″ Round

8″ Round

10″ Round

12″ Round


6″ Square

9″ Square

12″ Square


serves 8-10

serves 18-20

serves 25-35

serves 40-50


serves 10-12

serves 35-45

serves 50-60










Our sheet cakes are 2 layers of cake with 1 layer of filling.

1/4 Sheet

1/2 Sheet



Birthday Cakes

Kids Cakes

Bridal & Groom Cakes

Sculpted Cakes

Religious Cakes

Graduation Cakes

Baby Cakes

Corporate Cakes

testimonials View more...



Copyright© 2018 Sarah's Cake Shop & Sarah's On Central. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Domain 85